Coming up with names is the fun part. Choosing one is where groups get stuck: twelve suggestions in the chat, three people who feel strongly, and everyone else quietly hoping someone else decides. A little structure fixes that. Here's how to get from a pile of ideas to a name the whole group is happy with, usually within a day.
Pick one person to run it
Someone needs to collect ideas, build the shortlist and announce the result. It doesn't have to be the person who cares most about the name. In fact it's often better if it isn't. Their job is to keep things moving, not to choose.
Collect ideas, then close the door
Give everyone a set window to suggest names, such as until the end of the day. Ask for suggestions in one place (one thread, one note, one shared list), not scattered across side conversations. When the window closes, stop taking new ideas. Late suggestions are the most common reason name votes drag on for weeks.
Build a shortlist of three to six names
A ballot with 20 names spreads votes so thin that the winner might have only two supporters. Trim the list first:
- Drop anything that doesn't fit where the name will be used: a league sign-up, a work channel or printed shirts all rule out some names. (Our step-by-step naming guide covers this.)
- Merge near-duplicates. "Pin Pals" and "The Pin Pals Bowling Club" are one idea.
- Remove any name that one member has said they don't like being the joke of.
- Make sure the list has a range, such as one funny, one clever and one classic name, so the vote is a real choice.
Choose a voting method that fits your group
For most groups the simplest method is best. Here are the common options and when each works.
One person, one vote
Everyone picks their favorite and the name with the most votes wins. It's quick and everyone understands it. The downside is that with five or more names, the winner can have only a small share of the votes. Keep the shortlist short and this rarely matters.
Approval voting
Everyone votes for every name they'd be happy with, and the name with the most approvals wins. This is a great fit for group names, because the goal is a name nobody dislikes, not one a few people love. It's easy to run in most chat polls: just allow multiple answers.
Rank your favorites
Everyone ranks the shortlist, and you give each name points (for example 3 points for a first choice, 2 for a second and 1 for a third). It's the most thorough method, but it takes more effort to vote and to count, so save it for big decisions like a family reunion name that will be on shirts for years.
Two rounds
Vote once, keep the top two, then vote again. This works well for large groups, such as a class reunion committee or a big extended family, where one round would leave a lot of people unhappy with the result.
Make voting easy
The more effort voting takes, the fewer people do it, and a name chosen by three of twelve people won't feel like the group's name. A few things help:
- Use one link or one poll. If your group is split across iPhone, Android and different chat apps, a built-in chat poll may not reach everyone. A shareable vote link that opens in any browser does.
- Don't require sign-ups. Every account or download you ask for loses voters.
- Let people change their vote. People often change their minds once they see the names side by side, and being able to switch makes them more willing to vote early.
- Show the results. Watching the count is half the fun.
NameMyGroup's group vote was built around these ideas. Heart names from any page, tap "Start a group vote" on your shortlist, and share the link. Friends vote without an account, can change their vote, and see results update. When everyone has voted, the organizer closes the vote to lock in the winner. Votes are deleted automatically after 30 days.
Set a deadline
Announce when voting ends, and keep it short: 24 to 48 hours is plenty for most groups. Send one reminder halfway through, mentioning people by name only if your group is comfortable with that. When the deadline passes, close the vote even if a couple of people haven't voted.
Breaking a tie
Decide how you'll break a tie before the vote starts, so nobody can accuse the organizer of picking a favorite afterwards. Some fair options:
- Quick runoff: a second vote between just the tied names, open for a few hours.
- Guest of honor decides: for a birthday trip, bachelor or bachelorette party, or a retirement, let the person being celebrated choose.
- Combine them: sometimes two tied names can become one, like a name for the chat and a different one for the shirts.
- Flip a coin. It's fair, it's fast and nobody takes it personally.
Announce it and use it
When the vote closes, rename the chat right away (see how to rename a group chat in each app), and put the name wherever the group will see it: the trip itinerary, the league sign-up or the shirt order. A name sticks once people start using it, so use it early and often.